I just spoke to Drew, a friend of mine who is a university Director of Athletics. We talked about the Cornell University tragedy and what his response should be as he leads his coaches and student-athletes. Let me summarize the story.
On October 19, 2024, a 20-year-old female student, identified anonymously as Jane Doe, went to the Chi Phi fraternity house in Ithaca, New York. According to her lawsuit, fraternity members gave her alcohol and the drug ketamine, making her unable to give consent, and they assaulted her for hours.
Court documents cited by The New York Times revealed messages that crudely invited a group to join them. What few know is that 57 young men got the Snapchat message that a woman was available if they wanted her. Seven went over and committed the acts of sexual assault on the unsuspecting victim. Fifty did not go.
For those fifty, it would be easy to assume, “Hey, I didn’t join in the crime. I did the right thing.” While that is true, I wonder if we stop short when we assume they did nothing wrong. The fifty who didn’t join in knew what was about to happen—and they didn’t try to stop it. In today’s culture—a culture that assumes we should never judge anyone; one that believes it’s not our place to correct someone’s behavior—we fear stepping in to prevent wrongdoing. Our society is certainly good at jumping in once a tragedy occurs. We are problem solvers. Think about how Americans responded after the Twin Towers fell. Think about how so many responded after Hurricane Katrina. For that matter, think about how we’re responding now to this crime at Cornell University. We are amazing armchair quarterbacks after everything becomes obvious.
The Culture in Which Generation Z is Growing Up
Generation Z is growing up in this culture that’s either afraid to step in early or that doesn’t want the backlash that comes from acting before something happens. Our narrative is “don’t judge.” After all, we have different values. We come from different backgrounds. We are all unique individuals. While I agree with these statements, we are missing something profound. There is an unwritten but very real “social contract” we have with each other. Our society cannot function well unless we look out for each other. Inside every one of us are two tugs on our heart:
I want to be me. (I can enjoy purple hair, tattoos, piercings, and clothes I want).
I want to belong. (I need a community around me for support and accountability).
This may mean we make personal sacrifices for the betterment of the larger community.
Our early American fathers understood this and knew that a democracy cannot exist without this kind of moral fabric woven into our mindsets. We are social creatures who are not meant to live in isolation and by our own rules. Not if we want to live well. In fact, if we are merely “rugged individualists,” it would be chaos. Dog-eat-dog. Survival of the fittest. Every man for himself. But—is that what we really want?
Are we OK in a society that doesn’t do the wrong thing—but fails to do the right thing?
We Know Better
You probably remember the Marjorie Stoneman Douglas High School shooting back in February of 2018. A gunman killed 17 people at the high school. It was a massacre. But another story surfaced following this tragedy. Scott Peterson was the on-duty campus deputy who stayed outside the building during the shooting without entering to confront the shooter. Prosecutors charged him with felony child neglect. He resigned following the incident. But please note: Peterson wasn’t charged for something he did, but for something he didn’t do. A responsibility he failed to keep.
And what about the Robb Elementary School shooting in Uvalde, Texas? Over 370 officers from local, state, and federal agencies responded to the scene, but they waited 77 minutes before a tactical team finally breached the classroom and killed the gunman. Nineteen kids and two educators were killed by the gunman as adults stood outside. The incident was characterized by the Justice Department in its Critical Incident Review “as a catastrophic failure of leadership, tactics, and communication.”
Martin Niemöller was a German pastor who spent eight years in German prisons and Nazi concentration camps during World War II. He is famous for writing:
❝First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist. Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a trade unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.❞
There’s a passage of scripture, written centuries ago that sums up this principle:
❝If anyone, then, knows the good they ought to do and doesn’t do it, it is sin for them.❞
— James 4:17
I am not challenging people to be “judges” because we feel morally superior. I am saying we must be advocates, acting on behalf of everyone’s well-being—the perpetrator and the victims. I am challenging all of us to be countercultural; to swim upstream. Don’t just solve problems, prevent them. In doing so, the fifty young men might have been able to stop a tragedy.
Subscribe to future articles from Tim.
Book Tim for an event.